Audiation
for Conductors
A Music Learning Theory-Informed
Approach to Score Study
Audiation
for Conductors
A Music Learning Theory-Informed
Approach to Score Study
Gordon Institute for Music Learning International Conference
July 16, 2025, Chicago, IL
UMN TC Wind Band Conducting Workshop
July 18, 2025, Minneapolis, MN
Audiation, the ability to hear music in silence for which sound is not or may never have been present, is a necessary skill for conductors if they wish to engage fully in the art of studying and teaching music. Although score study is an individual process that will vary from conductor to conductor, the ability to hear music vividly in the mind is a fundamental skill that must be developed if one wishes to develop an aural image of the music prior to the first rehearsal without the aid of recordings.
The following score study process is my own that I continue to develop through practice and research. Although it will likely not be useful for other conductors to duplicate this process exactly, I am presenting it here in hopes that it offers insight into how audiation might play a role in your own study process.
Click to read more and see examples for each step:
Create a document for the piece, and make notes about the composer’s biography, the history of the piece, instrumentation, etc. Before moving onto the next step, you should be able to write your own program note for the piece.
I also do my phrase analysis here and identify the harmonic center of each major form element (only when the form is obvious in the score).
Application:
Sample crib sheet
Begin by identifying a line to audiate in silence, and then establish a consistent reading tempo. Once these are set, establish tonality by playing a few chords at the piano or “singing-into” the key (e.g. "Sol La Sol Fa Mi Re Ti Do"). Then read the selected line by audiating in silence while trying to vividly imagine the timbre of the instrument you are audiating. Do this without singing out loud or using an instrument to play the notes for you. It is often more beneficial for me to read one line from one rehearsal marking to the next instead of trying to read the entire piece in one go. When you get lost, don’t stop. Instead, try to improvise until you get to a familiar section of the music, and then go back and check your improvisation, it is probably closer than you think!
Once you have audiated one line, move to the next, eventually you will start to hear the other lines in the background while audiating a single line, which begins to reveal the composite of these multiple parts. During this step, you will develop a strong sense of tonal and rhythmic syntax for the piece, which will make your improvisation/guessing more accurate when reading new lines.
In instances where my audiation is unable to support reading individual lines at a slow tempo, I might jump to step 3 with the intention of returning to this step once I can sense that my audiation is starting to engage. In some instances (e.g. with music that is more experimental or atonal) it might be more practical to just listen to a recording. All of these should be acknowledged as shortcuts, the true discovery will happen when you are silently studying and audiating. Use these tools to jumpstart your audiation only when it is needed, and repeat this step daily or as frequently as your schedule will permit.
Application:
Use the following steps with the excerpt below.
Sing into the key and select a reading tempo
Select a line to read
Try to hear the line vividly in your head at your reading tempo
Select another line, repeat step 3 until you have read all lines
OPTIONAL: Check your accuracy by listening to a recording (not recommended for pieces you are studying for performance)
Repeat this process as frequently as possible until you find yourself audiating the score while you are not actively studying
After audiating each line in silence, identify one line to sing while playing another at the piano. Pay careful attention to the way the two lines interact harmonically, perhaps sustaining some notes to check your intonation. Playing multiple lines while singing another is a helpful skill for hearing parts within the context of full chords, but will require practice for those with less piano experience. I often reduce chords to root position while singing at the piano.
Application:
Use the following steps with the excerpt below.
Sing into the key and select a reading tempo
Select a line to sing (violin 1) and a line to play (violin 2) from mm. 1-8
Complete the Silent Study process with both lines if you have not already done so
Perform one line at the piano while singing another, allow your body to move expressively with the music as if you were performing on your primary instrument/voice
Switch lines, repeat this process until you can audiate both lines vividly
OPTIONAL: Check your accuracy by listening to a recording (not recommended for pieces you are studying for performance)
At this step, we identify form, harmonic motion, and thematic material. It is best to avoid beginning the study process with a full Roman-numeral harmonic analysis, because reading the music horizontally often reveals the deeper structure of the music much faster than looking for cadences and harmonic motion. In fact, it is often not necessary to identify every chord in a piece; an understanding of how the formal structure corresponds with shifts in harmony is often enough for developing a rich aural image of the piece.
Application:
Use the following steps with the excerpt below.
Identify the key center and starting chord, analyze others as needed (cadences are suggested at a minimum)
If you have not already done so, mark your phrases and form using whatever system works best for you
Label key theme areas (e.g. "A section, B section" or "Theme 1, Theme 2, Transition, Development" etc.)
Try to do this with your audiation first, then check with a recording if necessary.
*The full score cannot be provided here as fair use only allows sharing of 10% or less of a full work for study purposes. A complete score can be purchased through Ficks Music.
Experiment with your aural image of the piece by trying to imagine all possible interpretations for key phrases or lines. For instance, “What if the balance in this section was a little more horn dominant?” Or “What if the tempo relaxed here into the cadence?” You might also experiment with how you could accomplish each of these texturally, as it might prove useful in rehearsal. This stage isn’t about being correct, but it is about finding possible options for how the music might “go” through thoughtful play. This is much more difficult to accomplish if you have taken the shortcuts mentioned in stage 2 without substantial silent reading practice.
Much of this step happens away from the score for me; if I have developed a vivid enough aural image of the piece from steps 2-3, I generally find myself audiating through the piece while I am doing mindless tasks like washing the dishes, walking the dog, driving, etc. Sometimes my memory of the piece is incorrect and I will find myself missing a meter change or incorrectly remembering the contour of a phrase. When I find that I am having consistent mental slips in a particular section, that section becomes the new focus for my silent study. The fluency that results from this practice will also assist with designing the skill learning sequence activities that will be discussed below.
Application:
Use the following steps with the excerpt below.
Sing into the key
Pick one line and try to hear it vividly in your head at your reading tempo
As you read, imagine all of the possible ways that a performer might interpret it. (e.g. should m. 1 move quickly through b. 1-2 and slow down through b. 3-4, or should it accelerate through to b. 2 of m. 2? How soft should the first note begin (and what would that look like for a violinist)?
Move expressively as if you are performing the line, you don't need to bow or move your hands, but sometimes it helps to try
Think from a conductor's perspective - what gesture might elicit the sound that you imagine the performers creating? How might a performer respond to the gesture you are trying?
Repeat this process indefinitely, and engage students in it during rehearsals
Once you have reached this point in the study process, avoid listening to recordings until at least the first rehearsal
This is the final step of the score study process, and often happens twice for me: First when nearing the end of my preparation before the first rehearsal, and then again after hearing the interpretation of the musicians at the first rehearsal. Here we make decisions about how the work goes based on our orientation and analysis. Avoid listening to recordings here.
The amount of time that it takes to really understand a piece of music varies from person to person, so make sure to give yourself enough time to learn the piece fully. Because my own audiation skills are still developing, I like to have several months for a piece to live in my audiation before the first rehearsal. Some teachers might feel comfortable with a few weeks or even a few days of preparation. Knowing that whatever prep time I have during the day is often spent answering emails and meeting with students, I try to frontload my score study during the spring and then work one cycle ahead of the students during the school year.
When I study the repertoire for my University Band, my timeline usually looks like this:
April-June: Pick repertoire for the next year
May-June: Begin score reading for the big pieces (all concert cycles) for the next year, complete Step 1 casually as I have time, this might bleed into summer break, but I try to limit it to 20-30 minutes per day
August: Complete Steps 4-6 for first cycle music
September: Begin first cycle rehearsals, start score reading for second cycle smaller pieces
October: Complete Steps 4-6 for second cycle music
October/November: Begin second cycle rehearsals, begin studying smaller pieces for first concert cycle in Spring semester
December/January: Complete Steps 4-6 for Semester 2 first cycle music
- Repeat for the second semester...
Once a conductor has a vivid audiation of a score, they will be ready to design exercises that help students to understand the deeper structure of the piece. Although much of the Skill Learning Sequence involves rote learning, this is more than just teaching the piece by rote: Skill Learning Sequence activities are designed to teach music literacy skills. Musically literate students do not need to rely on their teachers to teach them their parts. For example, rather than teaching tonal patterns found directly in the piece, we expose students to a wide range of tonal patterns in the tonal syntax of the work. When students then encounter strings of patterns when reading new music, they will have the ability to audiate them in their mind and then recreate it on their instrument.
The following exercises can be done in the instrumental music classroom at any level of development (beginners through college), and will help the students and teacher to challenge their audiation skills. It is my belief that students learn best when they can see their teacher learning. Do not shy away from exploring the full sequence just because you might be intimidated by improvisation, embrace your weaknesses and allow yourself to grow alongside your students.
To learn more about Music Learning Theory and the Skill Learning Sequence, visit: GIML website
Aural/Oral Example:
Bambucco - Victoriano Valencia
UW Madison University Band
At the Aural/Oral stage, we echo patterns provided by a teacher or model without labels or notation. This is the first stage of formal music learning, and is the stage in which new patterns can enter our musical vocabulary. Even advanced musicians can benefit from regular practice at the Aural/Oral level, so although it may feel very elementary THIS STAGE SHOULD NOT BE SKIPPED (see below video of college students doing this work).
Some important notes:
At the Aural/Oral level, use a neutral syllable such as "bum", "buh", "ta", or "loo", although it is theoretically possible to engage at this level of the Skill Learning Sequence by performing on instruments, it is generally advisable to remove any executive skill barriers (e.g. tonguing, bowing, etc.).
Patterns may be excerpted directly from the repertoire, but since students are already going to experience them in rehearsal, it is often better to create other patterns within the tonal/rhythmic syntax of the piece.
Having students audiate patterns in silence can be just as powerful a teaching tool as having them perform them out loud.
Verbal Association Example:
Major I and V functional patterns
Mt. Pleasant 6th Grade Orchestra
At the verbal association stage, we add labels to patterns already performed at the Aural/Oral level. The choice of which solmization system to use is not as important as the consistency of using one system during audiation development, although I advocate for function-based systems such as solfege with movable-Do (and La based minor) for a tonal system and the Gordon or Takadimi systems for rhythms.
At the partial synthesis level, we learn to discriminate between different contexts that are already in our audiation. These differences could be duple/triple meter, major/minor tonality, etc. Changing the meter of a familiar song and asking students to identify within the song when the micro beats change is one way to engage in partial synthesis.
At the symbolic association level, we add symbols to musical elements already in our audiation. Rather than teaching new skills (e.g. fingerings, etc.) while also teaching note reading, using an MLT approach ensures that students are only being expected to learn one new thing at a time. It is not necessary for students to understand the theory of why things are notated in the way they are (e.g. explaining time signatures and key signatures), this level is simply stating that “the thing that sounds like this looks like this”. Most method books are not designed with a sound before symbol approach in mind, however, introducing songs by rote before expecting students to read the notation is one way to engage in symbolic association in our classrooms.
At the composite synthesis level, we learn to string together groups of patterns that are already in our audiation through reading or writing, and we are able to identify the syntax that these patterns exist within.
Symbolic Generalization Example:
Bambuco - Victoriano Valencia
UW Madison University Band
During the generalization stage(s), we perform or read unfamiliar patterns without the aid of a teacher or model. This stage can be broken into three sub-categories; Aural/Oral, Verbal, and Symbolic.
Here are a few examples from each of these three categories
Aural/Oral: Without labels, Teacher sings an unfamiliar pattern and students echo without labels
Verbal: Teacher sings an unfamiliar pattern without labels to students, students sing the same pattern back with labels
Symbolic: Students perform unfamiliar patterns from notation (this is called sight-reading)
Although improvisation is generally reserved for advanced ensembles at the secondary and post-secondary level, we have the capacity to engage in improvisation very early in our musical development. Improvisation can be as simple as me singing a tonal pattern to my students and having them sing something different back with the same function (e.g. I sing “Do Mi Sol” in major tonality and you might sing back “Mi Sol Do”). If we remove the guidelines to stay in the same function and simply say to “sing back something different” I might sing a major tonic pattern and they might sing a major dominant pattern. This is an example of creativity, not improvisation.
Creativity: Creating something different without restrictions
Improvisation: Creating something different within a set of restrictions (when improvising over a bebop chart, the restrictions are the chord changes and form: performers are still welcome to ignore them, but those guidelines remain).
Once students have a developed vocabulary of audiated tonal and rhythm patterns, and have demonstrated success with reading, writing, and improvising with familiar and unfamiliar musical materials, they should be ready to finally engage with the theoretical elements of music. These elements could include (but are not limited to):
Identifying notes using letter names
Labeling musical intervals
Learning key signature names and their associated scales
Identifying and naming chords and their harmonic functions
Labeling different types of cadences
Applying aesthetics to music based on historical context
In order to truly engage in Steps 2, 3, 5, and 6, of the score study process outlined above, we must be able to engage with a huge vocabulary of tonal and rhythmic patterns at the Theoretical Understanding stage of the Skill Learning Sequence (which assumes that we have previously engaged with that same content at prior levels of the sequence). The broader our musical vocabulary, the more quickly our brains are able to process the information contained in the score.
The learning process is cyclical: The same exercises that we use to teach musical vocabulary to our students will inevitably lead to the expanding of our own vocabularies. As our students learn, we must expand our own vocabularies in order to keep them challenged in class. This in turn, benefits our own score study, which will help to extract even more skills that we can teach to our students in the future.
It is my hope that this information is accessible and helpful to practicing teachers and students alike. Learning to audiate has brought me a great deal of joy both as a musician and as a teacher, and it has freed me to think more creatively about my music making.
Feel free to reach out with any questions or ideas: r.louis.vajda@gmail.com